Bay Island

Welcome to Bay Island

Located on the beautiful barrier island of Siesta Key, off the coast of Sarasota FL, Bay Island offers the utmost in upscale island living. This gorgeous waterfront community offers quick access to the ICW, Sarasota Bay, and the sparkling waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Bay Island real estate is situated at the north end of the island, allowing for incredible views of the Sarasota skyline and the Bay. This luxurious community is an amazing place to call home!

Search Bay Island Homes for Sale


Attention Bay Island Homeowners!

Considering selling your property in Bay Island? Rest assured, homes in this desirable neighborhood command premium prices due to high demand. To ensure you capitalize on this opportunity, we provide a complimentary home evaluation, accurately assessing your property's current market value. Our aim is to assist you in maximizing your equity and achieving the optimal return on your investment.

Get Your Home Value!

By giving us your phone number and email address, you are giving Lee Brewer permission to contact you via email, phone, or text.

Latest Sold Homes in Bay Island


Bay Island at a Glance

Getting Around

Siesta Key: 6 min.
Downtown Sarasota: 12 min.
Sarasota Bradenton International Airport: 23 min.


County: Sarasota
School District:
Sarasota County Public Schools
Median Home Value:

Spotlights of Bay Island

Shopping & Dining

Residents of Bay Island revel in the abundance of shopping and dining options, with Downtown Sarasota just a short drive away. From eclectic boutiques in Siesta Key Village to fine dining establishments in Sarasota, there's something to suit every taste.

Parks & Recreation

Bay Island provides ample opportunity for outdoor recreation, with direct access to the Gulf and Siesta Key Beach just minutes away. Whether it's fishing in the Gulf waters or enjoying water activities at Siesta Key Beach, residents have plenty of options for outdoor enjoyment.

Arts & Culture

The cultural scene on Bay Island enriches residents' lives, offering captivating experiences such as the Ca' d'Zan Mansion and the Sarasota Ballet. Sarasota's dynamic arts community, complete with theaters and museums, adds depth to the cultural landscape. Residents have access to a myriad of enriching cultural experiences, from exploring architectural wonders to attending world-class performances.

Find Your Home in Bay Island

If the Bay Island seems like your ideal neighborhood for your next home, we're here to assist you every step of the way! Reach out to the Lee Brewer today to discover more about this vibrant community and begin your journey towards owning a home in Sarasota. We eagerly anticipate the opportunity to meet you and help you find your dream home in the Bay Island.